Saanich recently approved a lighting variance at a new development of detached homes in the exclusive 10 Mile Point neighbourhood. The change involved removing a single streetlight from the development because residents enjoyed the dark sky at night and felt the light would “dramatically pollute the nighttime ambience of this semi-rural street” and frustrate dark-sky enthusiasts.
The Cadboro Bay Residents Association said the area “had historically protected rural values while eschewing broad streets, sidewalks and overhead lights.” They continued that development “must in turn respect those things that give value to lives, property and the natural environment.” Coun. Karen Harper agreed, saying “This is obviously an issue that is important … that the spirit of the communities are maintained in a way that is meaningful.”
This decision shows that municipalities can align their policies with residents' concerns in a respectful and cooperative manner. Unfortunately, this is not how Saanich has approached community plans in Shelbourne, Quadra, and other areas where many residents feel their lives, property and environment are under attack. This is because instead of finding out what kind of future residents want and providing ways in which the municipality could help them achieve these goals, Saanich takes a paternalistic approach, presenting essentially complete plans that leave residents with little or no capacity to influence their future.
I think it is fair to say that most Saanich residents prefer less light and noise pollution, more sunlight and privacy, more green space and mature trees, preservation of their long-standing community relationships and resources, and an acceptable rate of change. Yet a large segment of residents must accept the rapid transition of their suburban communities into high-density areas and transportation corridors despite doing everything they can to support a different path. They are left with the frustration, inequity and financial harm created by the process.
Perhaps the next time residents clap when they hear speakers expressing the sentiments they feel, Saanich councilors will reflect on their part in creating the situation.
Aidan Byrne
Saanich
