We are writing to express our concerns about Aryze Development’s proposed 197-unit housing project at 1934 Hovey Rd., undertaken in partnership with the South Vancouver Island Housing Society.
Despite recent adjustments to the proposal, this development continues to be far outside the land use for the site identified in the official community plan (OCP) and disregards the expressed values of our community and some members of council.
While Aryze has reduced the height of one building facing East Saanich Road, the six-storey structure on Hovey Road – immediately adjacent to the “orphaned” ALR home – remains unchanged in height and mass. This token gesture fails to address significant OCP policies, such as ensuring sensitive transitions to adjacent single-family homes and avoiding orphaned properties. Moreover, this location is outside the established commercial village centres of Brentwood Bay and Saanichton, where taller developments with community benefits are supported and encouraged.
Aryze has touted a $1-million amenity package as part of its proposal, but it is not directly tied to the project and offers limited community benefit. In light of the district’s substantial recent investments in amenities, such as the $4.9-million Centennial Park multi-sport box, this contribution is underwhelming. Council should carefully consider the optics of such an offering, which risks being perceived as an attempt to influence approval.
It is also disappointing that our invitations for dialogue with the Legion Manor and Coun. Paltiel (who brought forward the motion to reconsider this development) have largely gone unanswered. Such dismissive behaviour undermines trust and collaboration within our community.
Rejecting this proposal would enable council to focus on initiatives better aligned with the OCP and community priorities, including housing projects in more appropriate locations, such as closer to the village centre and hospital. This is an opportunity to uphold our community’s values and ensure thoughtful, sustainable growth.
Brian & Josée Smith
Central Saanich
